Poll: Best LCD backlighting choice?

by Richard Lawler posted May 16th 2009 at 12:00PM

Last week we took a peek into plans for future HDTVs, but it's 2009 and for buying an HDTV in the here and now there's only a few flat panel choices - while plasma definitely has its fans, facts are gentlemen (and most buyers) seem to prefer LCDs. As seen at CES, every manufacturer has kicked the competition for backlighting and image quality up a notch, with higher quality CCFL backlighting and even LED trickling to lower end brands, most notably Vizio's planned $2,000 55-inch HDTV due later this year. Further confusing things, though Samsung will also have an updated local dimming LED backlit line on shelves later this year, it's currently touting slim, energy efficient edge lit LED models, despite their slightly lower picture quality, while some top of the line LCDs with older CCFL lighting keep pumping out high quality pictures. So we bring the question to you, of the technologies currently on the market, which one has you convinced it's a good buy?

Filed under: Polls, Displays, LCD, Plasma

Tags: backlighting, backlit, ccfl, edge lit, EdgeLit, led, local dimming, LocalDimming, poll

Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)

Neutral

Netsurfer @ May 17th 2009 1:23PM

I've voted for local dimming technology,
BUT it needs to be DEVELOPED!
I mean:
- better color accuracy
- no "haloing" effects (e.g.: white-led backlight - Sammy 786,796,956)
- better input lag for gamers

Neutral

corey smith @ May 16th 2009 2:33PM

you know, that XBR8 is one hell of a TV. it can even out- black a Pioneer. if it wasnt for that stupid viewing angle drop off...

Highly Ranked

Roger @ May 16th 2009 4:56PM

The XBR8 does not have superior black levels compared to the Kuro's. Maybe next time around.

Highest Ranked

Billy @ May 16th 2009 5:52PM

No LCD has yet to beat a Pioneer Kuro or especially Elite or Elite Signature in blacks, color accuracy, gray-scale, or moving line resolution.

However, I have to admit I like the Sony XBR8's from my experience selling them side by side with the Pioneer Elites, Samsung A950's of last year and the new 6000 - 8000 series.

Neutral

Loban @ May 18th 2009 9:44AM

It's true, please don't even attempt to compare any LCD with a KURO please. For that matter, don't bother trying to compare an LCD with a high end VIERA either.

Neutral

ProcrastinationXtravaganza @ May 18th 2009 7:13PM

I'm with you, XBR8 FTW! I prefer it to the Kuro, I just can't get with plasma. The Sony is way overpriced, so no one's buying, the price is dropping, and haggling is back - find a local store, have cash, and lowball.

Neutral

corey smith @ May 19th 2009 1:34PM

@ roger, loban, and billy,

you know, if all you fanboys actually bought pioneer Tvs, they would still be making them. go do your homework guys- there is a tv on the market with darker blacks (and better motion rez) than a Kuro. those two aspects alone don't make the xbr8 a better set, but can't i mention a fun fact here without being castrated by fanboys?

Neutral

Loban @ May 18th 2009 9:44AM

If someone forced me to buy LCD, I would go with local dimming LED because I prefer the "highest picture quality possible". But given the fact that I prefer the "highest picture quality possible", I'll stick with plasma, thanks.

Neutral

riverside_guy @ May 18th 2009 11:33AM

While I generally would always go LCD, I have a far more serious issue... it seems all the latest LCD sets use high gloss screens. For many, that WAS a big factor in going LCD as opposed to plasma. For me, such a highly reflective screen just can't be used... I have a LOT of windows on all sides of the room and at times need something like a table lamp by my side.

Soooo, that actually will make me postpone any upgrades... and possibly lead me to an OLED!

Neutral

Anitesh Jaswal @ May 19th 2009 10:17PM

Well, plasma all the way. Local Dimming is a close second, and all edge-lit sets from Samsung look promising, but I mean, its a freaking TV. Not a goddamn fashion statement, and I truly scoff at customers who want it because it looks sexy. Ill give Samsung brownie points for making one hell of a good looking TV, but that doesn't justify he $5000 (CAD) price tag the 55" 8000 comes with. There are just as many other good looking LCDs, that give a more superb PQ, but are chunkier.

All the customers I tend to deal with, are either in the middle or dead set on LCD. I have to ask why they give plasma the hate, and it always comes down to "ohh it dies out after a while", and "it gets too hot"

Worthless excuses, especially when I trot over to the demo wall, throw in a movie, and on ANY plasma, show the 'informed customer' just how out of touch he/she is. Even 720p sets from Samsung and Panasonic manage to hold their own against the 1080p LCDs. Not saying you need to drop 6 gs on a Elite, but that doesn't mean your XBR8 is worth its stupid sticker price. I guess its really personal preference, mine would be in the basement, so the choice was the Kuro. And ohh baby, I don't regret it.

Neutral

Scott @ May 20th 2009 1:51PM

Why go with the side lit LED with lower picture quality, when vizio is coming out with the backlit LED 55 inch later this year, it will have a better picture, plus it's cheaper. Sounds smart to me.

Weekly Webcomic Wrapup is preparing to enter the fray Left 4 Dead 2 pre-loading now available through Steam Dragon Age: Origins gets patched, tool set released	You spend more time on MSN Messenger than ANYTHING else Mozilla Jetpack contest winner harnesses GPU power to process data Fugly Friday : Aiseikai Hospital has no opthamologist on staff
Yes, the Apple Store is ~~down~~ up Worm rickrolls unsecured jailbroken iPhones via SSH Heads Up: Update your Apple TV to 3.0.1 ASAP, says Apple	Six top trades for the rest of 2009 Earnings highlights: CBS, Comcast, News Corp., Time Warner, UBS, Viacom ... Trade #3: Market Vectors Gold Miners ETF (GDX)
Reminder: Watch the first episode of Halo Legends today Homemade Fallout 3 Shishkebab, make 'em now before the apocalypse Gears of War 2 celebrates first anniversary with triple XP	VIDEO: Mind the pole, please Gordon Murray working on EV version of city car? Hubinette to drift Smart Fortwo chasing Tom Cruise in Night and Day
Edited Left 4 Dead 2 PC has better performance? Splinter Cell: Conviction novel out now GoGamer.com brings us some pre-Black Friday sales	Ryan Moats Earns Texans' Starting Job Bucs Legend Excited to Christen Team's Ring of Honor Broncos Sign Veteran CB Ty Law