Toshiba's XD-E500 upconverting DVD player caught in stores
[Thanks, Philip]
[Thanks, Philip]
Relevant Posts
- Toshiba's 1080p REGZA ZV series LCD HDTVs get priced and dated (24 days ago - 4 Comments)
- Upscaling gets broken down and explained in layman's terms (2 days ago - 11 Comments)
- Toshiba's XD-E500 upscaling DVD player lands in Singapore (14 days ago - 14 Comments)
- DLO starts shipping HomeDock HD upscaling iPod dock (11 days ago - 7 Comments)
- Toshiba's XD-E500 player: now with free 1-year Lovefilm subscription in UK (25 days ago - 5 Comments)
Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
UnnDunn @ Sep 14th 2008 12:23AM
It doesn't carry the magical Blu-Ray logo!!
BURN IT WITH FIRE!!!!
Harmin C. @ Sep 14th 2008 3:51AM
What a load of crap this is... I am a former HD-DVD fanboy and my television in the bedroom and hd-dvd player are toshiba but this is too much. My cousin purchased one of these before most stores got them. I asked him to bring it over to my house to see how it holds up to my LG BH200 blu-ray/hd-dvd combo which has Qdeo upscaling (rivals Reon HQV)...
I noticed little to virtually no difference in the upscaling of the Qdeo on my LG to the Toshiba XDE... Only difference was that it was a bit sharper with the sharp setting on. Otherwise it looked identical to my Qdeo upscaling. Those with HQV upscalers most likely won't notice much of a difference. I'd give my Qdeo the edge in some aspects and the XDE the edge in some aspects. But with blu-ray prices dropping pretty fast I'd be hard pressed to recommend anyone spend the $150+ plus on this. By the way I think Best Buy is clearing stock of their BH200's... Last time I checked it was down to 339.99 but its probably back up. If you want my advice, get the decent blu-ray player and forgo the XDE. Most decent upscalers such as Qdeo or Reon HQV will make this XDE seem worthless. But if you'd prefer to see for yourselves be my guest. In Canada, Blu-ray players are down to 299.99. The Sharp blu-ray player from last year is going for 199.99 at visions in canada today.
Heres hoping that Toshiba stops trying to get every drop of blood from its DVD cash cow and embrace the "blu" future. While this XDE is amazing, it would be better if Toshiba offered it in a blu-ray player. Or hell add another hd-dvd/blu-ray combo player. I know tons of people who would be happy toshiba supports its old formats just as SACD and DVD-A or VCD is still supported nowadays.
Mark @ Sep 15th 2008 6:25AM
It's just a decent upscaling DVD player. Not the best, and not the worst. It certainly doesn't contain a cell processor. I expect it will find its place amongst the multitude of other DVD players but it will not affect sales of Blu Ray one way or the other.
Brian @ Sep 14th 2008 4:13AM
I disagree, Harmin. Bring on the best DVD upscalers; I have no interest in BluRay Disc. It's just another standard that will go the way of the MiniDisc in far less than a decade.
Digital content distribution is king, as far as my needs go.
It looks like the studios may be planning something to give digital distribution a jumpstart:
http://www.engadgethd.com/2008/09/13/digital-entertainment-content-ecosystem-the-drm-of-the-future/
I purchased numerous television series on Amazon Unbox, but I purchase all my shows on XBOX Live Marketplace, now. The DRM hurts, but once the studios all get on the same page, I'm hoping they'll be able to work that out.
joe @ Sep 15th 2008 2:21PM
Digitial distribution is NOT king and will never be. All the ISP are starting to put caps on there customers downloads or making them pay more per data download. this is gonan make large HD movie downloads pointless. Not to mention downloadable HD movie still dont look as good as blu ray, and by no means will it ever have the amazing uncompressed audio blu ray does. If your a realy movie fan Digital downloads are crap. sorry.
mntwister @ Sep 14th 2008 12:30PM
A friend of mine who was hot for one of these got one a few days ago and had me over. What a joke. Fine if you want a decent upscaling player, and there's nothing wrong with improving technology that is already available, and if you are into downloads, that's fine too, to each their own. I am enjoying pure 1080p on the my blu-rays with lots of special features now in HD and lossless audio on virtually every blu-ray disc. There is simply NO substitute!
mntwister @ Sep 14th 2008 12:33PM
Oh and I forgot, I brought over my Denon 3930 player which has the Realta HQV cip, there's no comparison, the Realta beat Toshiba in every single aspect of the picture.
ppw @ Sep 14th 2008 12:56PM
How much is the Denon 3930? And how much is the Toshiba?
mntwister @ Sep 14th 2008 1:09PM
A HUGE difference in price. I wasn't talking about price though, but rather upconversion quality and what has come from Toshiba's own publicity department, that it beats "all upscalers and nears the quality of bluray disc." I am not going to search for that but it's right there on the Toshiba website. Fact is it does not come near the quality of a good blu-ray disc in picture (we compared 3 blu-rays with their newly remastered special edition counterparts), and it certainly does not come anyway close in sound.
If I didn't already own the Denon 3930 dvd player which has the Realta HQV, I would consider the Toshiba though provided I didn't have the money to spend. I am not anti-Toshiba in any way.I own several Toshiba pieces of electronics and they are very fine. I never did get into hd-dvd though.
Spiza @ Sep 14th 2008 8:34PM
Maybe if this was a news site, they would post like they are journalist?
Mike @ Sep 15th 2008 4:07AM
If something displays in like HD quality then information on the product is justified.
Now reviews may be pending so who knows if it does...but right now I don't see a problem informing the readers this is now out.
Mark @ Sep 15th 2008 6:31AM
"Nfinity, TT and H4idol's behavior wasn't as bad as this!"
Yes it was. If Nfinity wasn't banned he would have used any Toshiba or Blu Ray story for several very long emails about either a) DVD being good enough and how he was going to buy an amazing super upscaling player / TV to watch it, or b) digital downloads are the future etc.
Mike @ Sep 15th 2008 9:22AM
Nfinity was banned??? Thats too bad.. he had good info on the spurs engine and what not.
Wheres the free speech?
I hope he comes back..mayby Lexus or google plex
Jason W @ Sep 15th 2008 9:32AM
Wow it looks like alot of you guys have "friends" that bought one of these..... Sure.... Bash away.
Mr. Alexander @ Sep 15th 2008 9:50AM
here is the display i saw at BBY
http://www.flickr.com/photos/sublimephoto1/2857348527/
and it seems they are in stock....and probably have been since I took this lol
http://www.flickr.com/photos/sublimephoto1/2857348275/
Mike @ Sep 15th 2008 7:18PM
$150???? ouch for that they should have just kept making the HD DVD player and just put in this upscaling chip in it...so you could a least by some HD movies if you want as well. These aren't going to sell well tell under about $80
JayC @ Sep 15th 2008 10:50AM
Up-scaling in general is pretty much the same in 2008.