Serene scenes on HDTV no substitute for nature
Ruh roh. Seems you can't use the "it's good for my health" excuse to watch just one more hour of Sunrise Earth, as a recent study has shown that watching serene scenes on HDTV just doesn't have the same calming effect as does watching a similar scene in nature. The University of Washington-based study discovered that heart recovery rates in people exposed to minor stress were the same when viewing peaceful imagery on a plasma or starting directly at a blank wall. Yeah, a blank wall. It was also noted that heart rates dropped more quickly when these same folks viewed a calming scene through a window, suggesting that technology may not be ready to replace reality just yet in this particular case. We just have to wonder if they were using true HD signals on the display -- nothing gets our heart racing like a bad episode of Pool Watchers in SD.
[Thanks, Ben]
[Thanks, Ben]

















Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
Some Kid @ Jun 17th 2008 10:45AM
this was a stupid study for a stupid cause that had an obvious outcome
of course looking at simulation is not the same as looking at nature
trust me, this would be like having a study to see if playing GTA4 would have the same effect on you as actually killing 20 people a minute and robbing stores and stealing cars
really WASU?
shetaan819 @ Jun 17th 2008 12:20PM
The question is whether these people in the study even appreciate HD, can these people even tell the difference between 480i and 1080i.....someone whom truly appreciates HD i suspect would have felt more of a calming effect...
boxmyth @ Jun 17th 2008 5:08PM
Blank Wall (Blu-ray) has been added to your Netflix Queue at position 1.
DC @ Jun 18th 2008 10:47AM
Agree with SOME KID comment above about any simulation is worse than actually being there. But as the producer of Sunrise Earth, a show which takes a little bit to put together... like finding some visual spots on the planet, going there with a couple high res HD cameras, assembling some 140 edits over the hour show... I find myself asking whether the content recorded on the HD (high or low res) cameras was really that engaging... it was, according to the UWashington study, recorded by a rooftop camera of the scene just outside the study site. Previous studies which showed some health benefits of scenes of nature were not images of a parking lot. Lastly, there probably were some cool things to look at in that parking lot, if you got on your knees with a macro lens and recorded the ants collecting food.