Unfortunately these only offer 1080p upconversion for analog sources. I've long moved on from analog, so what I'd really need is top notch 480i and 1080i to 1080p upscaling via HDMI from my DVR. I think the only Denon receiver that offers this is their top of the line 5308CI with the Silicon Optix Realta HQV processing. Sadly, $5,000 is WAAAAY beyond my maximum budget for a new receiver. I hope great video processing trickles down to more reasonably priced receivers soon. Oh well, back to waiting mode.
Thanks, guys. My situation is that I have a decent Marantz pre-HDMI receiver. I was hoping to kill two birds with one stone by upgrading to a receiver that does both HDMI audio plus top-notch video upscaling. I'd considered a lower end HDMI receiver plus a separate outboard scalar already, but again I'm afraid that combination is pretty well out of my price range for now.
Worst case, I could just go with an inexpensive HDMI audio receiver and use pass-through only on the HDMI video. That way I'd continue to use the TV's internal scalar, which is okay but nothing to write home about. If I'm ever able to get my front projector I could reevaluate an outboard processor at that time, if needed.
Or, I could wait... I just know that within a couple of years max we're going to have Realta-quality video processing in midrange receivers.
One more follow-up. Mark, thanks for the pointer about the Gefen TV Scaler Pro. With a $699 list price, maybe I *could* swing it plus a midrange receiver... I'll check out the reviews.
For folks with pre-HDMI AVRs: consider a blu-ray deck with internal decoding (e.g. Panny BD50) and multi-channel analog outputs. Assuming you have such inputs (most higher-end AVRs from the DVD era have 5.1 analog in at least), you can avoid changing anything. Very little besides blu-ray needs anything past DD or base DTS over optical.
HDMI/HDCP is more to be avoided that "upgraded" to.
For folks with pre-HDMI AVRs: consider a blu-ray deck with internal decoding (e.g. Panny BD50) and multi-channel analog outputs. Assuming you have such inputs (most higher-end AVRs from the DVD era have 5.1 analog in at least), you can avoid changing anything. Very little besides blu-ray needs anything past DD or base DTS over optical.
HDMI/HDCP is more to be avoided that "upgraded" to.
Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
Mr. E @ May 23rd 2008 11:01AM
Unfortunately these only offer 1080p upconversion for analog sources. I've long moved on from analog, so what I'd really need is top notch 480i and 1080i to 1080p upscaling via HDMI from my DVR. I think the only Denon receiver that offers this is their top of the line 5308CI with the Silicon Optix Realta HQV processing. Sadly, $5,000 is WAAAAY beyond my maximum budget for a new receiver. I hope great video processing trickles down to more reasonably priced receivers soon. Oh well, back to waiting mode.
Erwos @ May 23rd 2008 11:20AM
Just buy a VP30 or VP50 if you really need crazy-good digital upscaling.
Mark Garrett @ May 23rd 2008 1:16PM
Another option is the Gefen TV Scaler Pro. About 1/3 the price of a VP50. Uses the Realta chip for scaling.
Mr. E @ May 23rd 2008 1:44PM
Thanks, guys. My situation is that I have a decent Marantz pre-HDMI receiver. I was hoping to kill two birds with one stone by upgrading to a receiver that does both HDMI audio plus top-notch video upscaling. I'd considered a lower end HDMI receiver plus a separate outboard scalar already, but again I'm afraid that combination is pretty well out of my price range for now.
Worst case, I could just go with an inexpensive HDMI audio receiver and use pass-through only on the HDMI video. That way I'd continue to use the TV's internal scalar, which is okay but nothing to write home about. If I'm ever able to get my front projector I could reevaluate an outboard processor at that time, if needed.
Or, I could wait... I just know that within a couple of years max we're going to have Realta-quality video processing in midrange receivers.
Decisions, decisions... :)
Mr. E @ May 23rd 2008 1:48PM
One more follow-up. Mark, thanks for the pointer about the Gefen TV Scaler Pro. With a $699 list price, maybe I *could* swing it plus a midrange receiver... I'll check out the reviews.
http://www.engadgethd.com/2008/02/11/gefen-tv-scaler-pro-realta-hqv-1080p-upconversion-for-699
kcmurphy88 @ May 26th 2008 5:17PM
For folks with pre-HDMI AVRs: consider a blu-ray deck with internal decoding (e.g. Panny BD50) and multi-channel analog outputs. Assuming you have such inputs (most higher-end AVRs from the DVD era have 5.1 analog in at least), you can avoid changing anything. Very little besides blu-ray needs anything past DD or base DTS over optical.
HDMI/HDCP is more to be avoided that "upgraded" to.
kcmurphy88 @ May 25th 2008 10:27AM
For folks with pre-HDMI AVRs: consider a blu-ray deck with internal decoding (e.g. Panny BD50) and multi-channel analog outputs. Assuming you have such inputs (most higher-end AVRs from the DVD era have 5.1 analog in at least), you can avoid changing anything. Very little besides blu-ray needs anything past DD or base DTS over optical.
HDMI/HDCP is more to be avoided that "upgraded" to.