re: media center vs TiVo. I found I had to spend close to half the cost of a TiVo HD for a video card that would display HD without glitches (with a Dell XPS 420 quadcore). If TiVo would upgrade their nic cards to gigabit, there wouldn't be a question at all. I know everyone says it doesn't need the additional speed, until your moving .tivo files back and forth betwen your computer and additional TiVos. A gigabit connection would almost make this transparent.
Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
Joe Maki @ Mar 26th 2008 7:22PM
re: media center vs TiVo. I found I had to spend close to half the cost of a TiVo HD for a video card that would display HD without glitches (with a Dell XPS 420 quadcore). If TiVo would upgrade their nic cards to gigabit, there wouldn't be a question at all. I know everyone says it doesn't need the additional speed, until your moving .tivo files back and forth betwen your computer and additional TiVos. A gigabit connection would almost make this transparent.
Ben @ Mar 26th 2008 7:24PM
The reason it doesn't matter is because the TiVo doesn't even have the power to take advantage of the 100Mbps nic it has now.
As for playing HD on a PC, I used to do it with a P3 700 and a Radeon 9500, so any video card sold today will work fine.
But even if you do want the latest, you can buy a Radeon 2600XT for less than $100, which is less than 1/3 the price of a TiVo HD.