Poll: What Blu-ray player will you be picking up?
[Image courtesy of AV Revolution]
[Image courtesy of AV Revolution]
Relevant Posts
- Walk Hard's BD-Live features get tested on Sony's PS3 (43 days ago - 28 Comments)
- The 6th Day's BD-Live features get shown off on PS3 (36 days ago - 7 Comments)
- Forthcoming BD-Live rollout gets inspected (49 days ago - 0 Comments)
- PS3 firmware 2.20 bringing BD-Live interactive Blu-ray this month (57 days ago - 62 Comments)
- Hands-on with the PS3 2.20 update -- and now, we wait (52 days ago - 48 Comments)
Reader Comments (Page 1 of 3)
Anonymous @ Feb 20th 2008 11:05AM
As of now the best deal and most future proof player is ps3, and since I don't care about universal remotes and anything greater than hdmi 1.3a, it's definitely the best choice for me
rock99rock @ Feb 20th 2008 11:19AM
With Bluray readers dropping below the $200 price point for desktops, the HTPC solution is far more future proof as well as cost-effective.
mattclarkie @ Feb 20th 2008 11:26AM
I assume because the HTPC has in comparison to a standalone infinite RAM/Storage it could do profile 2.0 via an upgrade.
Mr. E @ Feb 20th 2008 11:48AM
Once again, I need to put in a plug for the Darklite PS3 IR remote. It works great with my universal remote, and the IR receiver is connected to the PS3 by a USB cable, so you can position the receiver anywhere you like, and keep the PS3 tucked out of sight. I have mine on a 10' cable, in fact. On/off functionality doesn't matter to me, as I leave my PS3 on continuously, running Folding@Home when I'm not watching a movie.
Carlton Bale @ Feb 20th 2008 4:47PM
An HTPC blu-ray drive upgrade would be the most cost-effective. Unfortunately, there is no PC hardware capable of outputting 7.1 channel uncompressed audio over HDMI. The best you can do is 5.1 over optical/coax (toslink/SPDIF). There are a few video cards that output audio over HDMI, but is identical to the 5.1 SPDIF output. I'm waiting for PC hardware that can handle all the format has to offer.
mattclarkie @ Feb 20th 2008 11:07AM
Resident Evil Extintion. I so want to see that, but my bloody TV just wont arrive. Where are you so I can get my 1080p 24p on.
James Bowe @ Feb 20th 2008 1:53PM
I caught that on blu, pretty stupid movie, but some sick visuals. STAY AWAY FROM THE SAMSUNG BD-P1400. I have one, great picture, but the audio gets out of sync all the time. I guess it's a common problem.
HDpurist @ Feb 20th 2008 6:20PM
It plays PERFECTLY on the PS3, including all the BDJ 1.1 content. This is a quality disc though the PQ is probably the weakest (I'd rate it between 8-7.5/10). The film is entertaining though, best in the trilogy IMHO.
Pingmeister @ Feb 20th 2008 11:08AM
After Samsungs struggles with getting BluRay right I am sticking to Sony's PS3, which is likely to be their flagship and most popular player for quite a while.
DrXym @ Feb 20th 2008 12:17PM
Hopefully Samsung have gotten a clue. Their players look really pretty. I suspect we'll see a rebadged Samsung player being sold by Toshiba before long given their close relationship.
Austin @ Feb 20th 2008 11:08AM
The seemingly honest and knowledgeable young man at Best Buy reccomended a HD-A3. I'm going to buy them for everyone I know!
JillnBone @ Feb 20th 2008 11:09AM
Looking for a xbox 360 add-on.
Don @ Feb 20th 2008 12:21PM
Same here.
Mr Cool @ Feb 20th 2008 3:28PM
same here as well
mattclarkie @ Feb 20th 2008 11:10AM
Isn't the BD-P1400 Samsung, because I was about to plop down on that. And what about the Sony S500
JVirg1 @ Feb 20th 2008 11:10AM
The one you can get for under 500 dollars, that will do everything my HD DVD player did. It must have analog outputs as I am not spending close to a 1000 dollars to replace my 400 dollar receiver I bought less that 2 years ago. My HD DVD player also had PIP and interactive features.
Any suggestions?
Jake @ Feb 20th 2008 11:40AM
That'll be the Panny DMP-BD50. See here: http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/showthread.php?t=970806
Onboard decoding (or bitstreaming) of EVERY audio codec, plus analog outs, plus BD-Live. Although it may come it at $599 MSRP.
System48 @ Feb 20th 2008 11:10AM
I'll pickup the Blu-ray add-on for the Xbox to hold me over until a somewhat affordable Blu-ray DVR comes out.
Zeus.:God @ Feb 20th 2008 11:11AM
None of them... The only one I would consider is a PS3, but there is no real reason to get a Blu-Ray player- all thats going to happen is innocent consumers are going to get price-gouged to no end.
ben @ Feb 20th 2008 11:24AM
The reason HD-DVD players were so inexpensive was because Toshiba was desperately selling them at a loss to save their format. Sony has recently made advances to make the blue laser technology used in HD DVD and Blu-ray less expensive, so expect prices to go down.
Geoffrey Sperl @ Feb 20th 2008 1:44PM
Never took Econ 101, did you?
Anthony @ Feb 20th 2008 2:18PM
Now there's a clear winner prices should drop significantly as demand & scale will increase. I held out (like almost everyone else) & expect I'll own one by the end of the year (Christmas-time, most likely).
zachary miller @ Feb 20th 2008 11:12AM
Im so glad the more expensive format won out. NOT! It's still to risky, with the different profiles and sucky codec support I'm just gonna wait till hd downloads become somewhat standardized or Blu-ray profiles stop evolving beyond players ability to upgrade. I'm not gonna drop 400 dollars on something that is gonna be obsolete in a couple months. We will have to see where the players go from here.
hahaha @ Feb 20th 2008 11:12AM
Waiting until Black Friday at least. DVD's are good enough for me. Only want True HD sound on 7.1 analog can't find a cheap enough player that can do this.
CassilineKnight @ Feb 20th 2008 11:16AM
See this is the only problem with Bluray IMO...the movies are there. And so far I've bought about 45 titles so far at what I think are decent prices considering its HD and to me their high quality films...
However I have NO player to play them on.
Right now I'm really tempted to just get the Panasonic DMP-BD30. But to me that would be the height of stupidity when the BD50 is just around the corner.
To add the problem is the fact that the BD50 might not have 7.1 audio apparently? If it did I would have no hesistation waiting for it to drop.
Plus Daewoo has a Profile 2.0 Player coming out as well. Its called the Daewoo DBP-1000 and from what I've read its pretty impressive. And I'm sure Samsung & Sharp are secretly working on their 2.0 Player also...
Heres the link to the Daewoo Bluray Player btw...all the tech savvy people out pleast let me know if it sounds worth waiting for! It does look pretty.
http://wesleytech.com/daewoo-dbp-1000-blu-ray-player-profile-20-compliant/349/
All in all the Player outlook is grim. But if I was forced to make a decision I'd choose the "Wait & See" option.
andy @ Feb 20th 2008 11:16AM
I'm getting that new profile 2.0 player that has discrete IR and decodes all of the Blu Ray audio codecs.
I forget which one that is.
Jake @ Feb 20th 2008 11:41AM
That'll be the Panny DMP-BD50. See here: http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/showthread.php?t=970806
Onboard decoding (or bitstreaming) of EVERY audio codec, plus analog outs, plus BD-Live. Although it may come it at $599 MSRP.
mattclarkie @ Feb 20th 2008 11:19AM
DVD kept evolving, not necessarily the standard, but the players. I have an old player which can't do progressive, I have a new player without an HDD because I didn't want one.
The first people to buy recordable players got fudged when they found they could only do DVD-RAM or DVD+R and not DVD-RW. My player can only do DVD+RW, but I want them on DVD-R, so I have to transfer them to a PC and then to the DVD-R.
It is the risk you take, but you have to take the leap so you can experience better technology. I bought my Xbox less than 1 year before the 360 came out, but I don't regret that.
Joe @ Feb 20th 2008 11:23AM
Whatever model is the first 2nd generation Profile 2.0 model. Maybe I'll hold out for RS-232 like Ben too.
Blaktornado @ Feb 20th 2008 11:24AM
I don't have a HD TV so it's pretty pointless buying a blu-ray player...
kevin @ Feb 20th 2008 11:26AM
I'm not buying any HD player until they come down under $100. I can wait if it means saving a couple hundred dollars...more money for the beer and pretzels to chow down on while I'm watching the good ol' SD movies I have now!
jp @ Feb 20th 2008 11:28AM
Looking forward to seeing what Boothroyd Stuart Meridian will be putting out. They were always in the Blue camp, but were waiting for the format war to be over before they made their offering.
Galley @ Feb 20th 2008 11:28AM
My home theater is begging me to add the Denon to it, (along with a new Denon receiver). My wallet is insisting that I stick with my trusty PS3 and my old Sony receiver.
andyg8180 @ Feb 20th 2008 11:30AM
im not gettin any of them till their "Profile" situation is fixed... Screw a PS3...
Bizzy @ Feb 20th 2008 11:32AM
I'm waiting for the 360 add on
StrangeBum @ Feb 20th 2008 11:33AM
PS3 for me. But only once it gets another sweet price drop. When I see one with a price point closer to the $300 mark then I will be all set.
And hell, even though HD-DVD is dead, I will probably pick up a player on the cheap and get me some of them free movies with it. Might as well considering there is no loss in quality compared to BD and compared to standard DVD it will still look better. Eventually I will just start purchasing the BD movies though, but I'm completely taking advantage of the death of the other format.
ituga @ Feb 20th 2008 11:34AM
I'll hold out for the Blu XBox360 add-on.
RikF @ Feb 20th 2008 11:35AM
Blu-ray burner or player for the HTPC
Jake @ Feb 20th 2008 11:49AM
No bonafide next-gen audio codec support plus pricey system requirements = pass for me.
clads01 @ Feb 20th 2008 3:26PM
There *is* next gen audio support but only via analog out as of now. Via HDMI is coming. With drives under $200, I will prob go this route. A good choice if you already have the 'expensive' HTPC or gaming rig ...
plozen @ Feb 20th 2008 11:37AM
I'll be waiting until the holidays, when Profile 2.0 players are more plentiful and the features on the discs actually take advantage of Profile 2.0. Hopefully by then prices will have fallen and I won't have to shell out more than $500 to get a fully-functional player (I STILL can't believe an incomplete, more expensive technology won the format war, but I digress).
Leif @ Feb 20th 2008 11:37AM
A few days after I bought my $150 A30 on 12/26/07, Warner announced their deathblow. I knew the end was near and returned my A30 shortly thereafter. I ended up picking up a Panasonic BD30 at BB for $345 with 10 free movies (any 5 I wanted in the store + 5 by mail offer). It's a great player and performs 24p more consistently than the A30 did. I will consider selling it and upgrading to the BD50 when it's released for the DTS-HD and Dolby TrueHD decoders. Hearing uncompressed PCM through my BD30, it's hard to listing to lossy DD or DTS. The upgrade in audio in some ways seems more signifcant than the video. That is one reason, amongst others, why I never considered the PS3. In my opinion Profile 2.0 will never really matter to me, as I have profile 1.1 and won't plan to connect it to the internets.
For a person deciding what to do, if audio matters a lot, wait for the BD50. If you have a receiver that can decode DTS-HD/DD TrueHD, then you can get the BD30 right away too. If it doesn't matter too much, get the PS3.
Britboyj27 @ Feb 20th 2008 11:39AM
Already rocking the Pioneer Elite BDP-95FD.
Jason @ Feb 20th 2008 1:09PM
That's what I'm looking at. Just hoping that the price will drop a little soon! And I'm waiting to get my Pioneer Elite 42" Plasma, so HD isn't quite an issue yet.
JayHDDVD @ Feb 20th 2008 11:39AM
Panny bd30 all the way.
cckrobinson @ Feb 20th 2008 11:39AM
I'm considering adding a Blu-ray drive to my dusty HTPC.
Boscorooty @ Feb 20th 2008 11:42AM
Just built a HTPC with LG HD/BD burner drive. I have a bunch of HD-Dvds (y'know, the format without all the DRM, Region Codes, and $45 new releases) and I've picked up a few BDs (CE3K looks amazing.) Plus it'll do X264 and every other HD and SD codec. I have no intention of buying ANY BR standalone unless they finalize their spec, although I may get a PS3 oneday if some better games come along.
Leif @ Feb 20th 2008 11:48AM
Nice HTPC. I've recently developed a whole new appreciation for X264 after getting my first HDTV at the beginning of '08. It's getting a little tiring disconnecting my main pc and then reconnecting it to the Kuro.
plozen @ Feb 20th 2008 1:51PM
What video card do you have in yours? I'm looking to add a PC to my setup, but what I have now is not able to handle HD video OTA at all, very choppy.
Mike S @ Feb 20th 2008 11:46AM
I'm waiting for a $200 Blu-ray player with analog 5.1 outputs.