DirecTV anti-piracy case thrown out, smart card programmers breath easier
It's no secret that DirecTV has been on the hunt for content thieves for what seems like ages, but it faced a serious setback recently when "the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals tossed out a default judgment against a pair of alleged DirecTV television pirates, saying an unauthorized decryption device law the company invoked against them does not apply." Apparently, the duo of defendants were brought to trial after they allegedly purchased a smart card programmer and used it for less than legal purposes (like "repairing pirate access cards disabled by DirecTV countermeasures"). But reportedly, the satellite provider has been going after folks who purchase these things, assuming that their intentions must be ill. Still, the pair in question may face lesser chargers if they did indeed break other laws, but at least individuals who like to tinker with smart card programmers can (hopefully) go about their day without worrying over the carrier breathing down their neck. [Warning: PDF read link][Image courtesy of CBP]
















Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
willy the impeached @ Sep 13th 2007 1:50PM
Great if this holds up, but keep in mind this is the 9th circuit! The most overturned circuit, the circuit voted most likely to be stark raving nuts ... These guys go to starbucks, wear their Che shirts, bankroll Hillary Inc., make luddites seem technologically advanced and provide random legal opinions that would make Chavez proud.
Landlocked @ Sep 13th 2007 2:39PM
I thought DTV cards haven't been able to be programmed by hackers in 4 years??? Why are they still hunting down people to allege hacking when it supposedly can't be hacked??
KC @ Sep 13th 2007 4:52PM
The lawsuits are what has kept the hacks that have been done for the last 4 years out of the general publics hands. P4/P5 cards are hacked, it's just not a viable business to be in selling them or the code when DTV is still hunting H/HU card hackers from the last century. Not the industry has just moved on...
FTA FTW!
KC @ Sep 13th 2007 4:52PM
The lawsuits are what has kept the hacks that have been done for the last 4 years out of the general publics hands. P4/P5 cards are hacked, it's just not a viable business to be in selling them or the code when DTV is still hunting H/HU card hackers from the last century. Now the industry has just moved on...
FTA FTW!
ozona @ Sep 14th 2007 9:08AM
Breath or Breathe?
Dunc @ Sep 15th 2007 10:05AM
just testing