Battlestar Galactica on Xbox Live: Not HD, not widescreen, not at all satisfying
The recap episode of Battlestar Galactica was posted on Xbox Live Marketplace yesterday and we regret to inform you it was not high definition. We're not entirely surprised at the resolution, a 720p-encoded file would have been a long download, not to mention the Xbox 360's smallish 20GB hard drive. Unfortunately it gets worse, the presentation was in widescreen, but with included bars at the top and bottom as though it were intended only for 4x3 SDTVs. Why they opted for a version that looks like it was taped off of Sci-fi network onto someone's VHS we will never know, but with the artifacting and low quality of the file we cannot recommend this to anyone in good faith. Hopefully they will do better when the episode is aired on Universal HD in September and it will be presented natively in widescreen. Oddly, despite the low quality of this file, you can download two HD clips of upcoming kids show Viva Piñata that look fantastic; hopefully future downloads will follow their lead instead of the quick and dirty approach apparently used on BSG.
[Via Xbox 360 Fanboy]
[Via Xbox 360 Fanboy]























Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
Larry @ Aug 29th 2006 2:27PM
I was really looking forward to this download before I heard it was SD. Now I will just wait until it shows up on Univeral.
Scott @ Aug 29th 2006 2:41PM
MS needs to add external HDD support for video and music downloads. Keep game saves, demos, XBLA games locked to the 360 HDD.
I just don't see MS releasing a larger 2.5" HDD anytime soon that will have the capacity and affordability for consumers to be downloading HD content through the 360.
Rob Stevens @ Aug 29th 2006 2:41PM
It could be because they are selling this same movie on DVD for about $20, and don't want to cannibalize sales.
Dustin @ Aug 29th 2006 2:45PM
I think this is the same thing that was on iTunes.
LA Dave @ Aug 29th 2006 3:16PM
BTW, the version that aired on the NBC west coast back on the 13th was broadcast in 1080i.
I was pleasantly surprised that it was in HD.
It is about 4.5GB with commercials edited out. :)
Jellodyne @ Aug 31st 2006 4:04PM
> "upcoming kids show Viva Piñata"
Viva Piñata is an upcoming game, not a show.
Richard Lawler @ Aug 31st 2006 6:16PM
It is a computer animated kids show and a game. Both launch this fall.
http://4kids.tv/vivapinata/
smthng @ Sep 13th 2006 1:28PM
Just for your info, Cox On-Demand also has The Story So Far in the "FreeZone". You have to search by name (search for Battlestar), as it isn't listed anywhere that I could find. It's letterboxed for SD sets and the resolution and compression are horrible. But if you REALLY want to see it and miss the UniHD run, I guess the On-Demand is better than nothing.