Q. Why would anyone buy a Blu-ray player? (other than the PS3) A. Because it may have terrible quality.
I remember back to PS2 launch days. The DVD playback quality was slated in Hi-Fi magazines compared to (good) stand-alone players.
The same may hold for PS3.
Now people are going to tell you that the movies are digital and how can any player make them look better or worse than they are authored at. Well these are the same people who well tell you there is no benifit from a good upconverting DVD player. So go read an explanation of up conversion and all the problems that happen with non-native frame rates, interlacing methods and resolutions. The upconversion issue will become a moot point but all the other porblems will be hanging around. I know that in most house-holds holds the Ps3 will be downsampleing the 1080p source to 720p or 1080i. This will bring it's own bucket of issues such as Aliasing artifacts (bad).
The only saving grace for the PS3 is that it's harddrive and network connection allows for playback software updates. Let's hope that Sony do strive to improve any playback quality or bug issues.
Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
nemi @ Apr 27th 2006 5:05PM
Q. Why would anyone buy a Blu-ray player? (other than the PS3)
A. Because it may have terrible quality.
I remember back to PS2 launch days. The DVD playback quality was slated in Hi-Fi magazines compared to (good) stand-alone players.
The same may hold for PS3.
Now people are going to tell you that the movies are digital and how can any player make them look better or worse than they are authored at. Well these are the same people who well tell you there is no benifit from a good upconverting DVD player. So go read an explanation of up conversion and all the problems that happen with non-native frame rates, interlacing methods and resolutions. The upconversion issue will become a moot point but all the other porblems will be hanging around. I know that in most house-holds holds the Ps3 will be downsampleing the 1080p source to 720p or 1080i. This will bring it's own bucket of issues such as Aliasing artifacts (bad).
The only saving grace for the PS3 is that it's harddrive and network connection allows for playback software updates. Let's hope that Sony do strive to improve any playback quality or bug issues.