OTA HD demystified
Everyone knows that it's possible to watch TV with an antenna, but most people today don't
understand why anyone would want to. We have all read the horror stories about how difficult it can be
to receive a good OTA (Over the Air) signal, especially with DTV. There are a few benefits to OTA today that we didn't
have before the US started the DTV
transition. Some of the best picture quality possible can be obtained with an antenna, at least until High
Definition DVDs are released. It's FREE, it's recordable on some computers like Windows Media Center Edition and it works sometimes when
cable and Satellite doesn't.
The first step to OTA nirvana is to research your area. Find out which stations are transmitting DTV and where the towers are located by using AntennaWeb, the foremost authority for OTA information. You simply submit your zip code and the website will return a list of all the channels in your area. It will also list where the towers are and how far you are from them. In addition, they also provide a recommended antenna type to help you choose the correct antenna. Your success will depend on where you live and your surroundings, so this is an important step. You can also see a street level map that will help you get an idea of the tower's location, for the directionally challenged. For those who need even more help, you can head over to HDTV Magazine and use their Google maps version which provides even more information. Plus - it's fun!
Not all the DTV stations are HDTV. Some of the stations don't choose to broadcast HDTV. Yeah I know it is crazy, but true. They might choose to multi-cast SD digital channels. One station in my area actually broadcasts 4 channels which are listed on my TV as 16.1 16.2 16.3 16.4. When the station chooses to do both HDTV and multicast it usually causes degradation in picture quality, but that is another discussion.

If you want to see what HDTV programming is available in your area you can check out TitanTV. They have a program guide that makes it easy to see what OTA HDTV is available . You have to sign up to use it but it's worth it. Once you login, you can go to the TV Listings section and choose "Digital Guide (Antenna)" to see the local line up. All the HDTV programs are clearly marked, but not always 100% accurate. Check in the evening since that is when most HDTV shows are on. You can also check out local HDTV forums for your area and see what other people are doing.
Now that you know where your stations are and what you can watch, it's time to find the right antenna. As you might guess, outdoor antennas are better and should be used if possible. As a compromise you can mount an antenna in your attic. There are a few indoor antennas that work well, but to obtain the perfect reception we want, we are going to use an outdoor antenna. Now if you study the information we obtained from AntennaWeb you will see that in my area not all the channels' towers are in the same direction. The channels I want to receive are 3, 8, 10, 13, 28, 38 and 44. These are the channels with HD content that I want to watch. Lucky for me all of the channels except channel 10, are 14 miles away and in the same direction. Channel 10 is in the opposite direction and 25 miles away. That will be more difficult but we can address that with some additional equipment. The other important thing to notice about the information from AntennaWeb is that the digital channels are actually on different channels than they say they are. For example channel 10 is really channel 24. Thanks to PSIP it will show up on your TV as 10 but in reality it's channel 24. This is important because a different antenna is needed for channel 10 than for channel 24. This is because channel 10 is a VHF channel and channel 24 is a UHF channel.

Since I want to receive 2 VHF channels and 4 UHF channel from the southeast I will use a VHF/UHF combo antenna pointed in that direction. I also want to receive one UHF channel from the northwest so I will buy a separate UHF only antenna and point it northwest. I originally tried it with just one antenna but my reception of channel 10 was not perfect so I added the second one. I want to combine the two antennas so I only have to run one coax cable to my TV. If I used a regular combiner it could cause multi-path, which would hinder my reception. I could use a rotor or an A/B switch but those don't work well with TiVos since it can't control the switch or rotor. So I am going to use a JOIN-TENNA from Channel Master. They make them for every channel so you have to order the right one. I bought one for channel 24.
You can buy an antenna locally or if you are like me and like to buy things on-line you can check out Antennas Direct. They have great products and service, they will even help you pick out an antenna. Just email them and let them know your surroundings. You might also want to buy some miscellaneous supplies like a pole and wire to connect everything. You can pay someone to do this too but what fun would that be?

I mounted both my antennas on the same pole along with my JOIN-TENNA. I connected it all and used a compass to point the antennas in the appropriate direction. The exact channel direction of the tower is available on AntennaWeb. I adjusted my UHF only antenna by angling it upwards a little to improve the signal strength. After you point the antennas it is a good idea to check your signal strength with a meter in order to fine tune them. Most DTV tuners include a signal strength meter, but not all. So if yours doesn't have this feature then it will be more work. You have to check each channel to see if you can receive it and then make adjustments as needed. After each adjustment, check the other channels to make sure you don't mess the other ones up.
With my setup I receive all the channels absolutely perfect. No monthly fees, no drop outs! My total cost was about $200, plus my time. It was well worth it! I have this signal split 5 ways without a problem. Amplifiers can be used if you experience signal loss from splitting or excessively long coax runs. But remember the amplifier is used to overcome attenuation from passive devices and the length of the cable, not antenna problems.
Feel free to post any questions in the comments and good luck!
























Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
Martin VanMeter @ Jan 30th 2006 2:31PM
Life would have been so much easier if the television broadcasters had kept HD signals in the "UHF only" spectrum the FCC originally set out. Luckily, in my area all the broadcasters are using UHF but their digital signal strength is still low compared to their much more powerful analog signals. That will change eventually as analog "goes away" by 2009 or later. Thank you for the good article, I am continually amazed at how many people don't even know that digital HDTV is available over-the-air. There is a tremendous amount of deliberate mis-information out there about broadcast HD and what is required to receive it.
Ben Drawbaugh @ Jan 30th 2006 2:37PM
I couldn't agree more. In fact Antennas Direct has a list of all the stations. Lucky for most that there are not many VHF channels.
http://antennasdirect.com/HDTV_station_lists.html
Jim @ Jan 30th 2006 4:29PM
Ben - good article.. I never realizded the Jointennas existed.. I may try them.. VHF may be an issue here in Cincinnati as WCPO - ABC 9 broadcasts on digital 10 - vhf (luckly my uhf antenna picks it up ok) They have applied to stay there after the cut off date. CBS 12 in Cincinnati broadcasts on digital 30 (or 31..) anyway - they have applied to go back to 12 after the cut off.. so in cincinnati - vhf will still be needed to some degree. Question, ben - do you use a mast amp or just a cheap Ratshack amp on the other end to split the signal?
Someguy @ Jan 30th 2006 6:41PM
Interesting article ... I'm one of the many that had no idea this was even possible. Thanks for the info, but I have some questions:
I haven't watched tv through an antenna for probably twenty years. So, for the dumbasses out here, can someone please explain how this would actually work with my current HD TV/TiVo/Digital Cable setup? I add an additional antenna ..... then what? Watch it through my TiVo like I do every other channel? Bypass TiVo? Set the tv to a specific video mode? Someone ... please ... inform ... me ...
Thanks
CT Raider @ Jan 30th 2006 6:46PM
I am just finishing up a weeklong project of changing an existing OTA to a new UHF/VHF Channel Master (the biggest) along with a CM 7777 pre-amp with a rotor on a 23' mast on TOP of my roof (guy wires used). The ONLY HD I get so far is a couple of independent, public and worship channels 18 mi from home! ARGH! NO NETWORK HD! and this is 350.00 later.
Ben Drawbaugh @ Jan 30th 2006 7:50PM
Jim,
Thanks for the kind words. I don't use an amp at all. Despite the long run and the spliters I still have enough signal.
Someguy,
It depnds on your equipment. Your equipment has to have a ATSC tuner in it. If it doesn't you can connect the output of your ATSC tuner via S-Video to your TiVo. It won't be HD but it will be the best SD you have access to. The problem is getting the TiVo to control the ATSC tuner. More than likely you would have to buy a seperate ATSC tuner either a stand alone or a PCI card for your computer.
john Ott @ Jan 30th 2006 8:14PM
Another point of information usually not understood about OTA HD:
OTA reception is actually the highest quality HD currently available to the consumer. Cable is compressed via modulation and satellite is compressed via MPEG-2/4. The broadcast signal is uncompressed. Assuming a clean reception, no artifacts, etc. and a technically superior image.
Ben @ Jan 30th 2006 9:13PM
I have never heard of modulation being considered as compresion before.
Can you back this up or is this your interepretation of modulation?
Either way Cable isn't going to be any better than OTA since most cable companies pull their signal OTA too. But it is possible that it could be just as good.
Buzzcut @ Jan 31st 2006 9:31AM
I wish I had a flat roof! I only need to climb the ladder one story to get on my roof, but the peak is very steep and waaaaay up there.
I've got a similar set up: big UHF/ VHF combo antenna, and a pre-amp. All the channels in Chicago are located fairly closely to each other (if you're in the suburbs), so no need to use 2 antennas. We do have a digital on channel 3, unfortunately. VHF sucks, especially the low channels. Very suceptible to electrical interference.
OTA is great. HD looks awesome, there are lots of subchannels so there is more programming than you might think, and its FREE. No cable for me.
mpd @ Jan 31st 2006 11:11AM
What some don't understand is you actually get MORE channels in HD OTA than analog OTA.
For example my abc affliate shows a live doppler radar for weather along with my fox one and nbc one.
PBS has 3 stations now of a kids one, documentary/news one and a cooking one...oddly enough my cable co doesn't list them as OTA!!
In addition to all of this you can get quite a number of free stations with a FTA dish and free radio via shortwave
UCFFool @ Jan 31st 2006 1:17PM
What DigitalTV Tuner box do you have? I'm still holding out for HDTV's with built in tuner's, but if that time does not come I am curious where I could find a box with composite and/or dvi outputs.
Also, is it standard COAX w/ F-Connector cable you are using between box and antenna?
Martin VanMeter @ Jan 31st 2006 2:53PM
regular RG-6 75 ohm coax from antenna to box. Antenna may require a matching transformer 300 ohm to 75 ohm at the antenna connectors.
A good, but inexpensive HD tuner box is the Samsung SIR-T451 refurbished from www.refurbdepot.com. I have bought one for myself and 2 for family members and all are working fine. Has all the various outputs, including DVI
Tim B @ Feb 1st 2006 2:34PM
I use an indoor antenna on top of the stand that holds my TV. No climbing ladders or running coax through the house. I bought a terk antenna and use a myHD card in a PC I had to tune and record HD programin :) I get great signal most of the time, though for some reason I have to rotate the antenna 90 degrees for a couple stations to get a clean signal. I have played around with different placements of the antenna and this is the best I signals I can get.
The only catch is in windy weather, the signal seems to drop out more. Also if a person stands in one specfic spot, the signal will drop for most of the stations.
I do live within a few miles of the transmitters though, so YMMV. Anyway just wanted to add that you can get exceptional OTA HD reception with an indoor antenna.
tb2 @ Feb 6th 2006 1:28PM
Just added an HDTV receiver for OTA, also in Chicago suburbs, and delighted in the "extra" channels.
What I can't figure out is how to hook up the VCR - can anyone pls help? Do I need to split the antenna cable, and run both seperately, or do I put the VCR after the Samsung HDTV receiver, using the Ant In & Ant Out ports on the HD?
Any website for really good basic instructions?
Martin VanMeter @ Feb 9th 2006 12:49PM
cable from "antenna out" on tuner to "antenna in" on VCR. Feed from VCR will probably have to go to the TV on one of the alternate "VIDEO" in sources. A little bit of a hassle, you will have to switch to that VIDEO mode to see the output from the VCR. VCR will only record the standard definition signal, not HD.
tb2 @ Feb 14th 2006 2:18PM
Thanks, Martin! After a lot more reading, I've realized there is more than one way to skin this cat. Thanks for offering simple, jargon-free directions. :^)
BTW - watching OTA Olympic coverage in glorious wide-screen hi-def is FANTASTIC!
Casey @ Feb 20th 2006 6:45PM
The $5 telescopic rabbit ear antenna I got from Home Depot is all I need to get all network HD stations in my area (Sacramento). I'm probably about 15 miles from the source broadcasts. I tried buying an "HD" antenna for about $100, but it was actually worse. I returned it the next day.